In 2004 three fossilized fish were found in the Canadian Arctic that were hailed to be an important missing link in the evolution of fish to tetrapods (vertebrates with four limbs). The newly discovered specimens, called Tiktaalik, have been touted as one of the best proofs for Darwinian evolution (common descent), providing solid evidence for the transition from water to land animals.
But now a paper in Nature is reporting that approximately a dozen fossilized tetrapod footprints have been discovered in Poland that date to 397 million years ago, at least 10 million years prior to Tiktaalik, forcing biologists to push the origin of tetrapods back about 20-30 millions years earlier than previously believed. Tiktaalik cannot be a transitional form between fish and tetrapods if tetrapods existed prior to Tiktaalik! Like so many other supposed transitional forms touted in scientific circles and the press (think Archaeopteryx and Ida), Tiktaalik is a dead end.
January 12, 2010 at 1:38 pm
Thanks for posting this. Tiktaalik is the featured transition creature touted in the PBS Special. That is a gigantic problem, the PBS program doesn’t mention anything about this and how many families, kids and parents, are digesting these lies without challenge? Thanks again Jason.
LikeLike
January 12, 2010 at 3:17 pm
cs,
This discovery just came to light recently, so the PBS special could not have taken it into account. With that said, even before this discovery there were problems with the evolutionary story being spun around Tiktaalik that I doubt the PBS special highlighted.
Jason
LikeLike
January 13, 2010 at 5:02 pm
Just a note. I’ve learned that while we do not know the identity of the creatures that made these footprints, they were approximately the size of an crocodile.
LikeLike