An increasing number of professing Christians will acknowledge that the Bible is opposed to some practice, but then claim that God has evolved regarding the issue and the Spirit is speaking something different to the church today. Apart from the epistemological problems that such a claim entails, isn’t it interesting that the Spirit is always being more permissive today (just like our culture)? That’s quite strange, because when God has given new revelation in the past, it was not in the direction of moral permissiveness, but in the direction of moral stringency.
For example, in the OT God permitted divorce, but in the NT, Jesus called God’s people back to God’s ideal of lifelong marriage. The OT only prohibited the physical act of adultery, but in the NT Jesus expanded the concept of adultery to include one’s thought life. If the direction of moral change was always from being more permissive to being less permissive, why think God is moving in the opposite direction today (and why think God has changed His mind at all)?
Also, why is it that the Spirit only seems to be changing His mind on issues that our culture doesn’t agree with Him on? Why isn’t the Spirit rethinking love, forgiveness, and tolerance? When the only thing the Spirit changes His mind on are the things the culture has changed its mind on too, chances are you are not hearing from the Spirit at all.
July 8, 2024 at 8:46 pm
Excellent post, Jason. Although you are critiquing cultural relativism, which I agree with, I would like to extend this a bit beyond what you post here, but still remain relevant.
The reason why we as Christians say that the Spirit cannot change His mind is for the very same reason Christians state God cannot change. “Why is that?” someone may ask. Here is why:
Simply through the examination of Scripture, one may find that God Himself says he cannot change. For lying and changing the mind are demonstrations of things that change. Apophatically, God is changeless and timeless.
With this Scripture, we would go so far to say that it is not within God’s own nature to change. Hence why modern Christians wouldn’t be able to claim that God has changed His mind on command or principle A, B, or C for example. This is because His commands are based upon His very nature: being timeless, changeless, and goodness Itself.
LikeLiked by 1 person