Wesley J. Smith reports that the Dutch government is drafting a law that would legalize euthanasia for the perfectly healthy who feel that they have “completed life” and want to die. This is not surprising given the logic of the pro-suicide position. The two prongs on which it hangs are self-autonomy and ending suffering.
I’ve long thought that these two rationales would be decoupled, such that justifiable suicide would no longer require that both requirements be met. In this case, self-autonomy alone is the justification for suicide. A perfectly medically and mentally healthy person just wants to die. No more justification is needed.
Suicide opponents have always said assisted suicide is a slippery slope to death-on-demand. This new law is essentially a blank check for death-on-demand, and thus the Dutch have nearly arrived at the bottom of the slope. True rock bottom will be reached once suicide advocates start arguing that the ending of suffering in and of itself is justification for ending someone’s life. Without the requirement of autonomy, personal consent is irrelevant. Doctors will be allowed to actively kill those they (or family members) deem to be in too much suffering, even without their consent. This would be murder in the name of compassion, under the banner of “death with dignity.” This is already happening with newborns in the Netherlands (The Groningen Protocol). All that’s left to hit rock bottom is to extend this to all ages and codify it in law.
October 27, 2016 at 1:30 pm
Actually, there’s still some Velcro on that slippery slope. If one bothers to actually read the original Reuters article and do a little Google searching, it says the Dutch Health Minister “hopes” to draft legislation by the end of 2017 to allow those over the age of 70 to end their life, assuming she can find enough people to support her version of justifiable euthanasia . This after nearly every major religious organization on the planet and her own commission set up the study the idea rejected it. Similar legislation in the UK failed by over a 2:1 margin. Check back a year from now.
As for the Groningen Protocol, the criteria for those under the age of 12 are:
1. The presence of hopeless and unbearable suffering
2. The consent of the parents to termination of life
3. Medical consultation having taken place
4. Careful execution of the termination
Yes, the child doesn’t have to be consulted, but parental consent is required. The ethics are not black and white in such cases. What parent wants to see their child endure hopeless and unbearable suffering?
LikeLike